Prince Caspian

“You may find Narnia a more savage place than you remember.” Never have truer words been spoken. Fans of the 2005 blockbuster hit THE LION, THE WITCH AND THE WARDROBE will doubtlessly be surprised if they come into PRINCE CASPIAN expecting the same kind of fun and wonder that enchanted millions three years ago. Incessantly dark and serious, the film is a worthy successor even if it ultimately proves too downtrodden and frightening for its audiences.

Hundreds of years have passed since viewers last saw Narnia, and much has changed. The familiar Narnians have been pushed into the woods and the vicious Itali- er, the Telmarines- have taken control. When the self-proclaimed King Miraz (Sergio Castellito) discovers his wife has given birth to a son and heir, he realizes that the only thing that stands in the way of unending power is his young nephew Caspian (Ben Barnes). Caspian escapes into the vast woods with a magic horn in his possession. Suddenly, the four Pevensie children (Georgie Henley, Skandar Keynes, William Moseley and Anna Popplewell) find themselves transported back to Narnia. They soon realize that they must help Caspian rally the Narnians to fight for their very survival.

Where the first film was concerned mainly with the tight bonds the siblings felt for each other, PRINCE CASPIAN is concerned with battles. Much of the first film’s humor is gone; this sequel is a mostly serious affair. The lighter moments are only passing, quickly taken up by scenes of the oncoming enemy or questions about mortality that are surprisingly earnest for a family film. The sense of wonder has also been replaced by a large amount of violence. It is rather disconcerting to see the young stars of the film kill so many people without a second thought, especially when it is presented in such a straightforward manner. It is quite surprising that the film was only given a PG rating; it’s easily the most violent PG-rated film in decades.

There is also a lack of magic in the characters. While they are actually supporting characters, the Pevensie children are not nearly as compelling as they were before. While Peter (Moseley) and Susan (Popplewell) are given interesting subplots, Edmund (Keynes) and Lucy (Henley) are left to lurk more or less in the background. Lucy still is the series’ most likeable and innocent face, thanks to Henley’s easygoing charm; unfortunately, this means she is entirely absent for long portions of the film when the other characters go off to battle. As Caspian, newcomer Barnes makes a fitting and sympathetic hero. The film also suffers in its lack of a strong villain. Miraz is nothing more than a stereotypical evil warrior king – a far cry from the spellbinding figure Tilda Swinton crafted in the first film. When she appears midway through the film, it suddenly kicks into high-gear; her all too short appearance gives the film the edge it was trying to get at all the while.

Still, the film is more than a worthy successor. While lacking in magic, it reflects the maturation of its characters and audiences. It may have taken a step too far and become too serious and frightening to recapture moviegoers as the filmmakers did three years ago, but those that follow it adamantly will likely appreciate the higher stakes and wider scope. While solid, the film takes another step towards LORD OF THE RINGS rather than attempting to create its own style and voice.

**1/2/****